A pros and cons template helps you make a bounded choice by listing each argument on its own row and, optionally, scoring its importance from 1 to 5 so a single decisive point isn't outvoted by many minor ones. The recommended parts are the decision or question, a Pros column, a Cons column, an optional Weight column, and a decision line where you record what you decided and why. To weight pros and cons, score each point rather than counting rows, and treat the totals as the shape of the trade-off, not a verdict. Argumentree can turn a discussion or transcript into a weighted pro/con argument map automatically, keeping an audit trail of how the group reached the decision. Related tools: the AI pros and cons generator and the guide to decision-making.
A clean, free pros-and-cons list you can copy or download in seconds — with an optional weight per point so the important arguments actually count.
A pros and cons list is a simple decision-making tool that sets the arguments in favour of a choice against the arguments against it, side by side. Writing each point in its own row lets you weigh them against each other instead of going on a gut feeling — and it leaves a record of why you decided what you did.
Related: AI pros and cons generator and what is decision-making.
Question: Should we adopt a 4-day work week for the team?
| Side | Point | Weight (1-5) |
|---|---|---|
| Pro | Focus time goes up — fewer meetings spread across fewer days | 4 |
| Pro | Stronger hiring and retention signal in a tight market | 3 |
| Pro | Forces the team to cut low-value work to fit the hours | 3 |
| Con | Client coverage on the off-day needs a rota or clear async policy | 5 |
| Con | Some deep projects may simply need the fifth day | 3 |
Decision: trial it for one quarter with a Friday-off rota for client coverage; revisit against SLA data.
Illustrative example — replace with your own question, points, and decision.
Copy the empty template (a Side / Point / Weight table plus a decision line) into whatever tool you already use, or download it as a CSV for your spreadsheet. No sign-up needed.
A two-column list works well for a quick, personal choice — but once several people are involved it starts to hide who argued what. Argumentree can turn a discussion or a meeting transcript into a weighted pro/con argument map automatically: it extracts each point, groups the pros and cons, and keeps an audit trail of who argued what and how the group reached the decision. You start from the same pros-and-cons shape as this template, but the reasoning is captured for you instead of typed in by hand.
A pros and cons list is a simple decision-making tool that sets the arguments in favour of a choice (the pros) against the arguments against it (the cons), side by side. By writing each point down in its own row you can weigh them against each other instead of relying on a gut feeling, and you end up with a record of why you decided what you did.
At minimum: the decision or question you are weighing, a pros column, a cons column, and a notes or decision line where you record the outcome. A good template also adds an optional weight per item — a 1–5 importance score — so that one decisive point isn't outvoted by a pile of minor ones. The decision line is the part most lists skip, and it's the part that makes the list worth keeping.
Give each point a simple importance score — for example 1 to 5, where 5 is decisive and 1 is minor — rather than just counting rows. A long list of small pros should not automatically beat a single serious con. Add up the weighted scores on each side, but treat the numbers as a way to see the shape of the trade-off, not as a verdict that decides for you: a single 5-weight risk can be reason enough to say no.
Yes. Copy it as Markdown or CSV, or download the CSV, and use it in any tool — a spreadsheet, a doc, or a note — with no sign-up. Argumentree offers it as a free template; turning a discussion into a weighted pro/con map with AI is the optional next step.
A pros and cons list works best for a bounded choice with a clear question — should we do X, or should we pick option A over option B. For bigger or contested decisions with several people involved, a flat list starts to hide who argued what; that's where a structured, weighted argument map is a better fit than a two-column list.
Let Argumentree extract the pros and cons from your discussions, weight them, and keep a full audit trail of how the decision was reached. Free to start.
Start Free Trial