Loomio kayan aikin yanke shawara ne na hadin gwiwa wanda aka gina akan tattaunawa mai juyawa da shawarwari masu tsari tare da zaɓi (yarda, rashin yarda, jinkiri, toshe). Kungiyoyi yawanci suna neman madadin lokacin da suke buƙatar kama da kimanta dalilin, ba kawai zaɓin ba; shiga cikin al'umma na budaddiyar tushe a cikin manyan ƙungiyoyi; tarin ra'ayi a cikin manyan al'umma; yanke shawara bisa yarda; ko kasafin kuɗi na shiga. Argumentree yana kama yanke shawara a matsayin itatuwa masu jere na hujjoji, yana fitar da hujjoji daga takardu da takardu tare da AI, yana haɗa kimantawa daga mahalarta zuwa maki na yarda, yana riƙe cikakken tarihin bincike, kuma yana fassara cikin harsuna 66. Decidim, Polis, da CoBudget suna budaddiyar tushe; Murmur yana mai da hankali kan yanke shawara bisa yarda (sociocratic). Zabin da ya dace yana biye da amfani da ku, ba wani tsari guda ba.
Wani gaskiya na mafi kyauLoomiozabi — zaɓin tushen buɗe da tsarin yanke shawara, menene kowane ya fi dacewa da shi, da yadda za a zaɓa.
Loomio na yin abu guda da kyau: yana juya shawara zuwa tattaunawa mai jere tare da shawarwari da kuri'a (yarda, rashin yarda, jinkiri, toshe). Kungiyoyi suna fara neman wani wuri idan suna bukatar wani abu da ba a gina shi don —kamawa dalilinbaya ga hukuncin maimakon kawai sakamakon,bude tushe na shiga cikin al'ummaa matakin al'umma ko birni,ra'ayi gudaa cikin manyan rukuni masu yawa,tawali'u bisa yarda(shugabanci na zamantakewa) yanke shawara, kokasafin kudi na shiga hannu. Kayan aikin da ke ƙasa kowanne yana rufe ɗaya daga cikin waɗannan bukatun; haɗa kayan aikin da aikin maimakon bin "mafi kyau" guda ɗaya.
Wani dandamali na yanke shawara tare da haɗin gwiwa wanda ke ɗaukar dalilin da ke bayan shawara, ba kawai kuri'a ba. Inda Loomio ke tsara shawara a matsayin tattaunawa tare da kuri'a kan shawarwari, Argumentree yana tsara ta a matsayin tsari na hujjoji masu kyau da mara kyau — tare da fitar da AI daga takardun taro da takardu, kimanta mahalarta wanda ke haɗawa cikin maki na yarda, cikakken hanyar bincike, da fassara a cikin harsuna 66.
Wani dandamali na dimokuradiyya na budewa da aka gina a cikin cikakken tsari, wanda aka kirkiro a asali don birnin Barcelona kuma yanzu ana amfani da shi daga gwamnatoci, hadin gwiwa, da kungiyoyin al'umma. Yana goyon bayan hanyoyin shiga, taruka, shawarwari, muhawara, da kada kuri'a a matakin babba.
Wani kayan aiki na budewa don tattara da rarraba ra'ayoyi masu buɗewa daga manyan rukuni. Masu halarta suna gabatar da ra'ayoyi gajere kuma suna kada kuri'a, sannan Polis yana amfani da rarrabewar lissafi don bayyana wuraren da aka yi jituwa da kuma rarrabewa a cikin dukkan al'umma.
Wani kayan aikin yanke shawara da aka gina bisa ga yanke shawara na amincewa (sociocratic), inda shawara ke ci gaba sai dai idan wani ya kawo hujja mai ma'ana. An tsara shi don ƙungiyoyi da ke son yanke shawara masu sauƙi da ke dogara da ƙin yarda maimakon kuri'un rinjaye.
Wani kayan aikin hada-hadar kudi da kuma kasafin kudi na shiga wanda ke ba wa wata kungiya damar rarraba wani tarin kudi na gama gari a cikin shawarwari. Yana kara wa tsarin yanke shawara ta hanyar gudanar da matakin 'yaya za mu kashe shi' a fili.
Don bukatun makwabta:Kialo — Wani dandamali na muhawara da ilimi da aka shirya bisa ga itatuwan hujja na goyon baya/kiyaye — mai amfani idan bukatarka ita ce bincika bangarorin biyu na wani batu maimakon kaiwa ga shawarar rukuni. (Argumentree da Kialo). Thoughtexchange — Wani dandamali na haɗin gwiwa na nau'in bincike don tattara da fifita ra'ayoyi daga manyan masu sauraro — ya dace da tattaunawa mai faɗi, ba maƙasudin yanke shawara na ƙungiya ba. (Argumentree da Thoughtexchange).
| Kayan aiki | Haɗin gwiwa | Bude tushe | Fitar da AI | Kimar jituwa |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Argumentree | ||||
| Loomio | partial | |||
| Decidim | partial | |||
| Polis | ||||
| Murmur |
Kwatancen ƙwarewar da aka rubuta sosai; saitin fasalolin masu sayarwa yana canzawa — tabbatar da cikakkun bayanai na yanzu tare da kowanne kayan aiki.
Ba ka buƙatar kayan aikin shigo da kaya. Manna rubutun tattaunawar Loomio ko shawarwarin cikin Argumentree kuma AI ɗin sa zai sake gina shi a matsayin taswirar hujjoji mai tsari — yana fitar da takamaiman ikirari daga tattaunawar, yana tsara maki masu goyon baya da masu adawa, da haɗa hujjojin akasin. Tattaunawa mai ɗanɗano tana zama rajistar yanke shawara mai maimaitawa da ƙungiyar za ta iya kimanta da duba. Sabon ga wannan hanyar? Dubayanke shawara tare, yanke shawara bisa ga jituwa, and farashi.
Ya danganta da abin da ka girma daga ciki. Idan kana bukatar kama da kimanta dalilin da ya sa aka yanke shawara — ba kawai lissafa kuri'ar shawara ba — Argumentree yana tsara shawarar a matsayin itatuwa masu tsari na hujjoji, yana fitar da hujjoji daga takardun tare da AI, kuma yana tantance jituwa. Don shiga cikin al'umma na budewa a babban mataki, Decidim yana da kyau; don tarin ra'ayoyi daga manyan rukuni, Polis; don yanke shawara bisa amincewa a cikin ƙungiya, Murmur; da kuma don kasafin kudi na shiga, CoBudget. Zabin da ya dace yana biye da amfani da kai, ba wani tsari guda ba.
Eh. Loomio kansa yana da budadden tushe, kuma wasu hanyoyi suna da haka ma. Decidim dandamali ne na dimokuradiyya na halartar jama'a wanda aka kware a ciki, ana amfani da shi daga gwamnatoci da hadin gwiwa; Polis yana da budadden tushe kuma yana kware a tarin ra'ayoyi daga manyan rukuni; CoBudget yana goyon bayan kasafin kudi na halartar jama'a. Argumentree ba budadden tushe ba ne, amma yana bayar da matakin kyauta don farawa — abin da ya bambanta shi shine taswirar muhawara mai tsari tare da fitar da AI da kimanta jituwa maimakon tsarin lasisi.
Duk suna goyon bayan yanke shawara na rukuni a lokaci guda tare da rikodi. Bambancin shine tsarin: Loomio yana ɗaukar tattaunawa da zaɓi (yarda, rashin yarda, jinkiri, toshe); Argumentree yana ɗaukar hujja — kowace ƙalubale an tsara ta bisa ga shaidar da hujjojin da suka goyi bayan da kuma waɗanda suka ƙi, an kimanta ta daga rukuni zuwa maki na jituwa. Argumentree kuma yana fitar da hujjoji daga takardun taro da takardu tare da AI kuma yana fassara cikin harsuna 66.
Ba ka buƙatar kayan aikin shigo da kaya. Manna rubutun tattaunawar Loomio ko shawarwarin cikin Argumentree kuma AI ɗin sa zai sake gina shi a matsayin taswirar hujjoji mai tsari — yana fitar da takamaiman ikirari, maki na goyon baya da na adawa, da hujjojin adawa — don tattaunawar da ke akwai ta zama rajistar yanke shawara mai ma'ana maimakon zaren da ba shi da tsari.
Argumentree yana canza tattaunawa zuwa yanke shawara mai tsari — fitar da AI, kimanta jituwa, da cikakken hanyar bincike. Kyauta don farawa.
Fara Kyauta