A cikin taswirar tunani, kowanne node jigo ne ko ra'ayi kuma kowanne haɗi yana nufin "yana da alaƙa da"; tsarin yana zagaye kuma kyauta, kuma yana amsa "menene wannan game da?" — mafi kyau don bincike da tunawa. A cikin taswirar muhawara, kowanne node ikirari ne wanda zai iya zama gaskiya ko ƙarya kuma kowanne haɗi yana nufin "yana goyon baya" ko "yana adawa da"; tsarin yana da tsari na hierarchal pro/con itace, kuma yana amsa "shin wannan muhawarar tana da ƙarfi?" — mafi kyau don zaɓar da tabbatarwa. Su haɗa juna: yi tunani kan zaɓuɓɓuka tare da taswirar tunani, sannan ka yanke shawara tsakanin su tare da taswirar muhawara. Kayan aikin taswirar muhawara da aka keɓe sun haɗa da Argumentree, Kialo, DebateGraph, da harshe na Argdown; Argumentree yana ƙara fitar da AI, kimanta mahalarta wanda ke haɗawa cikin maki na jituwa, haɗin gwiwa a cikin lokaci, da fassarar harsuna 66.
Suna kama da juna — akwatuna da layuka — amma suna amsa tambayoyi daban-daban. Tsarin tunani yana taimaka maka fitar da ra'ayoyi; Tsarin hujja yana taimaka maka yanke shawara.
A taswirar tunani tana fitar da ra'ayoyi daga wani babban batu ta hanyar haɗin kai — mai kyau don tunani da tunawa. A taswirar hujja tana haɗa ikirari bisa ga ko suna gozawa ko kiyaye juna — an gina ta don gwada tunani da kai ga hukunci. Taswirar tunani tana ɗaukar abin da kake tunani akai; taswirar hujja tana ɗaukar ko yana daidai.
| Taswirar Tunani | Taswirar Tattaunawa | |
|---|---|---|
| Babban ra'ayi | Ra'ayoyi da aka tsara ta hanyar haɗin kai | Iyakoki da aka tsara bisa ga dangantaka mai ma'ana |
| Menene node? | Wani batu ko ra'ayi | Iyakacin da zai iya zama gaskiya ko karya |
| Menene ma'anar haɗi | yana da alaƙa da | tallafawa" ko "karya |
| Babban manufar | Tunanin, bayanai, tunawa | Tunani, kimantawa, yanke shawara |
| Tsarin | Radial, kyauta-tsari a kusa da tsakiya | Tsarin gina fa'ida/rauni na matakai |
| Tambayar da yake amsa | Wannan game da menene? | Shin wannan hujja tana da karfi? |
| Mafi kyau don | Bincike da tunawa | Zabar da kuma tabbatar da gaskiya |
Sabon ga ra'ayin? Fara damenene taswirar muhawara.
Argumentree wata dandalin taswirar hujja ne da aka gina don yanke shawara, ba don tunani ba. Yana canza tattaunawa da takardu zuwa tsarin itatuwa na pro/con tare da AI, yana ba wa mahalarta damar kimanta hujjoji don auna jituwa, kuma yana adana cikakken tarihin yadda aka kai ga kowace shawara — a cikin harsuna 66.
Tsarin tunani yana tsara ra'ayoyi ta hanyar haɗin gwiwa a kusa da babban batu — kowanne reshe ra'ayi ne mai alaƙa, kuma burin shine tunani da tunawa. Tsarin muhawara yana tsara ikirari ta hanyar dangantaka mai ma'ana — kowanne node ikirari ne kuma kowanne haɗi yana nufin 'tallafawa' ko 'kiyaye', kuma burin shine gwada tunani don cimma hukunci. Taswirar tunani tana nuna abin da kake tunani akai; taswirar muhawara tana nuna ko tana da inganci.
Yi amfani da taswirar tunani a farkon lokacin, lokacin da kake tunani, bincika wani batu, rubuta bayanai, ko kokarin tuna sassan wani abu. Yi amfani da taswirar hujja lokacin da kake bukatar tantance zabuka masu gasa, auna shaidu, warware sabani, ko yanke shawara da rubuta ta — a ko'ina inda dangantakar hankali tsakanin ikirari ta fi muhimmanci fiye da haɗin kai na kyauta.
Suna warware matsaloli daban-daban, don haka ɗaya ba ta maye gurbin ɗayan ba — amma suna yawan zama a matakai daban-daban na aikin guda. Taswirar tunani na iya taimaka maka wajen tunanin zaɓuɓɓuka; taswirar muhawara kuma tana taimaka maka yanke shawara tsakanin su ta hanyar tsara fa'idodi da rashin fa'idodi. Manyan ƙungiyoyi suna tunani cikin 'yanci a farko, sannan suna canza zuwa taswirar muhawara lokacin da ya yi lokaci don zaɓar ainihi.
Kayan aikin taswirar hujja da aka keɓe sun haɗa da Argumentree, Kialo, DebateGraph, da yaren alamar Argdown. Argumentree yana ƙara fitar da AI (mai juyawa rubuce-rubuce da takardu zuwa taswirorin tsari na goyon baya/kiyaye ta atomatik), kimanta mahalarta wanda ke haɗawa zuwa maki na yarda, haɗin gwiwa a cikin lokaci na gaske, da fassara a cikin harsuna 66.
Motsi daga tunani zuwa yanke shawara — tsara hujjoji da zaɓi tare da bayyana.
Fara Kyauta